I'd add a method to delete from disk items in the download manager (vs. the "Clean Up" button).
And on Tabs, I feel that that would functionally change how I use my browser and how I use tabs in the same sense that tabs changed how I used a single browser window.
I'd like to see something like a double-click on a stacked tab expand that tab and collapse all the other tabs (or even to spawn a new browser window with those tabs un-stacked).
I'd probably use one window with all Bugzilla tabs stacked, all newspaper tabs stacked and whatever else, and switch between then instead of having a browser window open for each (or scrolling tabs).
Sicking
· 2 years ago
What happens if not the last tab in a stack is the selected one? Right now it's always the "top" one in each stack that is selected, but what happens if another one is? Or is a tab always moved to the top of the stack when it is selected?
I would recommend against having a single tab in multiple stacks, that seem very confusing to me.
I'd also merge "add to tab stack" and "move to tab stack" into a single action. Even if a tab isn't in a stack the wording "move" sounds ok to me.
Finally, I really think it'd help if smooth animations were used while the tabs moved around. Once you have this many tabs and stacks it's going to be hard to see what is happening if things jump around like they do today.
dria
· 2 years ago
Suggestions noted! I'd love to see tab animations -- I think that's a much-desired feature that would improve user experience a bunch. I'm sure beltzner could wax poetic about that for hours. :)
Ant Bryan
· 2 years ago
I love the download manager mockups.
Gerv
· 2 years ago
Some thoughts, then:
What does Tab Stacks buy you? Haven't you just reinvented, er, windows (i.e. a way to group collections of tabs)?
On the Download Manager mockup, where do the ratings come from? What is the Type column for?
The tagging stuff looks interesting, but how does it fit in with Places? How do we get people past the "Hey? Where are my bookmarks? And how do I bookmark a page now?" thing?
funTomas
· 2 years ago
On Tabs, as I perceive it, the main reason for the outlined improvement is to save some UI real estate allowing for more tabs to be open. Well, the idea is nice especially when your "browsing behaviour" consists of jumping from site to site. But when working with multiple tabs of same site, it becomes a bit cumbersome and what's more, it still doesn't allow for drag'n'droping between two tabs. Check out my opinion at http://wiki.mozilla.org/User_talk:FunTomas
AndyEd
· 2 years ago
Downloads should remember their source URL.
See http://surfmind.com/muzings/?p=107 for some interesting ideas on presenting tags. Slightly heretical, I suggest you think about HTML UIs for tagged bookmarks, not xul. Or, at least a horiztonal bar for the selected tag with top co-occuring tag filters.
Archaeopteryx
· 2 years ago
Tab stacks: - There is only one tab per stack "big", shouldn't all tabs of the active stack have the same size? The other stacks could be reduce to drop-downs like in Fx2 if the tab bar can be scrolled. - For reducing confusion about tabs and stacks, another possibility would be to show only the active stack and place the others in a small vertical bar (like tabs) on the left (for western people, left for eastern).
Download manager: - Pause, resume, abort buttons per file - Progress per file (depending on server and file size) - Use tree or similar for setting download locations per file. - The icon should have an arrow into it (at the moment, it looks like common unzip/extract icons) - Offtopic: Saving a complete page should show it later as it was displayed in the browser (after executing scripts and without adding content which had been blocked by Adblock Plus etc.)
All Comments
And on Tabs, I feel that that would functionally change how I use my browser and how I use tabs in the same sense that tabs changed how I used a single browser window.
I'd like to see something like a double-click on a stacked tab expand that tab and collapse all the other tabs (or even to spawn a new browser window with those tabs un-stacked).
I'd probably use one window with all Bugzilla tabs stacked, all newspaper tabs stacked and whatever else, and switch between then instead of having a browser window open for each (or scrolling tabs).
I would recommend against having a single tab in multiple stacks, that seem very confusing to me.
I'd also merge "add to tab stack" and "move to tab stack" into a single action. Even if a tab isn't in a stack the wording "move" sounds ok to me.
Finally, I really think it'd help if smooth animations were used while the tabs moved around. Once you have this many tabs and stacks it's going to be hard to see what is happening if things jump around like they do today.
What does Tab Stacks buy you? Haven't you just reinvented, er, windows (i.e. a way to group collections of tabs)?
On the Download Manager mockup, where do the ratings come from? What is the Type column for?
The tagging stuff looks interesting, but how does it fit in with Places? How do we get people past the "Hey? Where are my bookmarks? And how do I bookmark a page now?" thing?
Well, the idea is nice especially when your "browsing behaviour" consists of jumping from site to site. But when working with multiple tabs of same site, it becomes a bit cumbersome and what's more, it still doesn't allow for drag'n'droping between two tabs.
Check out my opinion at http://wiki.mozilla.org/User_talk:FunTomas
See http://surfmind.com/muzings/?p=107 for some interesting ideas on presenting tags. Slightly heretical, I suggest you think about HTML UIs for tagged bookmarks, not xul. Or, at least a horiztonal bar for the selected tag with top co-occuring tag filters.
- There is only one tab per stack "big", shouldn't all tabs of the active stack have the same size? The other stacks could be reduce to drop-downs like in Fx2 if the tab bar can be scrolled.
- For reducing confusion about tabs and stacks, another possibility would be to show only the active stack and place the others in a small vertical bar (like tabs) on the left (for western people, left for eastern).
Download manager:
- Pause, resume, abort buttons per file
- Progress per file (depending on server and file size)
- Use tree or similar for setting download locations per file.
- The icon should have an arrow into it (at the moment, it looks like common unzip/extract icons)
- Offtopic: Saving a complete page should show it later as it was displayed in the browser (after executing scripts and without adding content which had been blocked by Adblock Plus etc.)
Tagging:
- Use meta keywords as default